ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s telecommunications operators struggle with the most basic financial metrics, revenues plummeting from $5.0 billion in 2016 to $3.4 billion in 2023 despite data consumption exploding by 335%, the government pushes relentlessly toward a 5G future that industry experts warn of dire financial consequences.
The Global System for Mobile Communications Association (GSMA) has delivered an ultimatum that reads like a ransom note: delay spectrum allocation by two years, and Pakistan loses $1.8 billion in GDP growth through 2030. Delay it five years, and that figure balloons to $4.3 billion. Yet the very operators expected to bid in the upcoming 2025 spectrum auction are hemorrhaging cash, operating with one of the world’s lowest average revenue per user at $0.80 compared to a global average of $8.00.
This is Pakistan’s 5G paradox: caught between digital transformation imperatives and brutal economic reality, where the cure for spectrum starvation might prove more toxic than the disease itself.
Pakistan operates as one of Asia’s most spectrum-starved markets, a digital desert where operators compete for scraps while regional neighbors feast at the frequency buffet. With only 270 MHz of assigned spectrum compared to the Asia Pacific average of over 700 MHz, Pakistan’s cellular networks are choking on their own success.
The numbers paint a devastating picture of neglect. According to GSMA analysis, Pakistan’s spectrum allocation puts it among the most constrained markets globally, falling behind Bangladesh, India, and even smaller regional players who have moved aggressively to modernize their frequency allocations. This scarcity isn’t theoretical, it translates directly into dropped calls, network congestion, and sluggish data speeds that frustrate millions of users daily.
Historical auction failures compound the crisis. Both the 2014 auction covering 850 MHz and 1800 MHz bands and the 2021 auction for 1800 MHz and 2.1 GHz bands resulted in unsold spectrum, primarily due to prohibitively high reserve prices that deterred bidders. The Pakistan Telecommunication Authority’s pricing strategy prioritized immediate government revenue over long-term infrastructure development, a shortsighted approach that has already cost the economy an estimated $300 million in lost benefits.
The contrast with regional success stories is instructive. Bangladesh conducted a $1.2 billion 5G spectrum auction in March 2022, while India’s massive $19 billion auction demonstrated robust operator confidence when pricing remains reasonable. Pakistan’s challenge isn’t operator interest, it’s creating auction conditions that reflect market realities rather than wishful government revenue projections.
The upcoming 2025 auction promises nearly 600 MHz across multiple bands including 700 MHz, 1800 MHz, 2.1 GHz, 2.3 GHz, 2.6 GHz, and 3.5 GHz. This represents Pakistan’s most comprehensive spectrum release ever, but success depends entirely on learning from past failures through conservative reserve pricing and realistic payment terms.
Behind the spectrum statistics lies a more disturbing story of industry financial collapse. Pakistan’s telecommunications sector presents a masterclass in how rapid technological change can destroy traditional business models when pricing policies ignore economic fundamentals.
The revenue crisis defies conventional business logic. As Pakistani consumers embraced mobile data with unprecedented enthusiasm, consumption growing from 2,493 petabytes in 2018 to 10,850 petabytes in 2022, operator revenues moved in the opposite direction. This inverse relationship between demand and revenue reflects Pakistan’s ultra-competitive pricing environment, where fierce competition has driven data costs to $0.12 per gigabyte, among the world’s lowest.
Market leader Jazz commands 34.5% of retail mobile market spectrum, followed by Zong at 24.5%, while Telenor and Ufone control 20.9% and 20.10% respectively according to Pakistan Telecommunication Authority data. However, market share means little when the entire pie is shrinking in dollar terms due to currency devaluation and regulatory pressure to keep tariffs low.
The proposed Telenor-Ufone merger, creating a combined entity controlling 41% of total retail spectrum, represents a desperate industry consolidation attempt. Post-merger, this new player would hold the largest shares across critical frequency bands while maintaining exclusive access to 850 MHz spectrum. Yet even consolidation cannot solve the fundamental problem: Pakistani telecom operates in an environment where spectrum costs consume approximately 20% of operator revenue, double the sustainable global benchmark.
The auction mechanics worked perfectly. Grameenphone and Robi each acquired 60 MHz in the 2600 band for approximately $336 million, while Banglalink took 40 MHz in the 2300 band for $224 million and Teletalk secured 30 MHz for $168 million. Spectrum was allocated, licenses issued, and the regulatory framework established for 5G launch by end-2022 or early 2023.
Read more: Petroleum Prices Likely to Rise Again In Pakistan Amid Global Surge
